If you’re on the hunt for the safest neighborhoods in Staten Island to visit or live, you’re in the right place. Whether you’re considering moving to this borough of New York City or are a long-time resident looking to relocate within the area, safety is likely high on your priority list. Staten Island is known for its rich history, 170 parks, and excellent beaches, but how safe is Staten Island, really? Keep reading to dive deep into the heart of Staten Island, exploring its tranquil streets, friendly communities, and serene parks. We’ll also provide data-backed insights into crime rates and safety measures, ensuring you have all the information you need to make an informed decision about your next home.
FAQs: Is Staten Island Safe?
Safety can vary greatly from neighborhood to neighborhood within any given NYC borough. While some areas experience higher crime rates, others are exceptionally safe, with active community involvement, vigilant local law enforcement, and lower crime statistics. So, how safe is Staten Island? It’s the safest borough in NYC.
Is Staten Island Safe at Night?
Staten Island boasts excellent nightlife and food options to enjoy in the evening. However, it’s always wise to maintain a degree of caution when traveling anywhere at night. Some areas of Staten Island have been flagged for higher crime rates and gang activity, including Park Hill, Port Richmond, Richmond Terrace, and Jersey Street. However, even in the safest areas, you should always be alert, keep your personal items close, and avoid traveling alone at night.
Is Staten Island Safe for Tourists?
While Staten Island, like every NYC borough, is not without its share of safety concerns, many parts of it are considered safe and welcoming for both residents and visitors. Tourists should stick to visiting the safest neighborhoods in Staten Island and avoid areas known for higher crime rates.
Is Staten Island a Safe Place to Live?
Overall, Staten Island is a safe place to live and call home. It’s generally known for its lower crime rates compared to other parts of New York City. The community vibe is strong, with close-knit, friendly neighborhoods that are welcoming and safe. Plus, it offers a great mix of urban and suburban living with plenty of parks, cultural institutions, and delicious cuisine. So, if safety and community are high on your list, Staten Island could be the perfect fit for you!
7 Safest Neighborhoods in Staten Island
Are you intrigued by the safety and beauty Staten Island offers residents? Our curated list of the safest neighborhoods in Staten Island will help you find the best area to call home.
1. Bay Terrace
Bay Terrace is a charming neighborhood on the East Shore of Staten Island, New York. Named after the street that centers its community, Bay Terrace is home to residents who enjoy the perks of residing in this coastal enclave. A distinctive feature of Bay Terrace is its close-knit relationship with water. Great Kills Harbor and several marinas within it are integral parts of the local lifestyle. Interestingly, a significant 4.6% of people in Bay Terrace commute by ferry each day, a notably high percentage compared to most places. The neighborhood is also known for its strong sense of community, supported by the numerous schools, amenities, and activities available. Plus, with Great Kills Park nearby, residents have ample opportunities for outdoor activities.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 161.1 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 14 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 0 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 175.1 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 0 (national: 284)
2. Rossville
Rossville is a vibrant and picturesque neighborhood on the South Shore of Staten Island. Known for its charming blend of urban and suburban living, Rossville offers residents a diverse range of amenities and attractions. The neighborhood is home to some of the top-rated schools, shopping plazas, malls, and restaurants, making it a convenient place to live. Residents enjoy the benefits of numerous parks, entertainment venues, and hospitals just minutes away. Furthermore, the real estate market in Rossville is quite robust, with homes for sale that cater to different tastes and budgets. The community’s rich history adds an extra layer of charm to this already appealing Staten Island neighborhood.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 125.8 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 4.5 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 31.5 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 220.2 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 13.5 (national: 284)
3. Westerleigh
The neighborhood of Westerleigh is steeped in history, with the Westerleigh Collegiate Institute being the first school on Staten Island to provide a complete kindergarten-to-college education. The real estate scene in Westerleigh is also lively, with homes having a median listing price of $737,000. Living in Westerleigh offers convenient access to various amenities, including schools, transit options, and recreational activities. The residents take pride in their community’s unique linguistic diversity, adding to the charm and distinctiveness of Westerleigh.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 112.9 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 35.3 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 42.3 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 352.8 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 7.1 (national: 284)
4. Great Kills
24,424 residents enjoy living in Great Kills on the South Shore of Staten Island. One of the most cherished aspects of the neighborhood is the abundance of dining options. From cozy coffee shops to a variety of restaurants offering diverse cuisines, there’s something for every palate. Great Kills is also home to several parks that provide a tranquil escape from city life. Perhaps the most notable among them is the Great Kills Park, part of the Gateway National Recreation Area, offering beaches, marinas, and fishing areas.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 168.7 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 34.4 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 48.2 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 285.7 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 17.2 (national: 284)
5. Arden Heights
Arden Heights is home to a diverse range of housing options, including single-family homes, townhouses, and condos, catering to different lifestyle needs and budgets. The area’s wealth of amenities is another highlight. Arden Heights boasts several parks, providing residents with ample opportunities for outdoor activities. Most notable is Arden Heights Woods, an 8-acre forested freshwater wetland that provides a unique nature experience within the city. Despite its urban location, Arden Heights retains a rural charm, offering residents a tranquil respite from bustling city life.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 134.3 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 16.3 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 36.6 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 305.3 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 4.1 (national: 284)
6. Eltingville
Renowned for its comfortable suburban feel and family-friendly atmosphere, Eltingville offers easy access to the amenities of urban living. The neighborhood boasts excellent schools, convenient shopping centers, and an array of restaurants catering to various tastes. With a population of just over 10,000, Ettingville is known for its tight-knit community spirit. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby parks and green spaces, particularly Blue Heron Park, which offers hiking trails, ponds, and bird-watching opportunities. Overall, Eltingville provides a balanced lifestyle that many find irresistible.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 192.5 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 18 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 78.2 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 469.2 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 12 (national: 284)
7. West Brighton
West Brighton is a delightful neighborhood that many residents find appealing for various reasons: the suburban setting features tree-shaded streets, well-maintained sidewalks, sprawling green spaces, and lakes, offering residents a tranquil and natural environment to enjoy. The food scene in West Brighton is also noteworthy, adding to the community’s vibrancy. In terms of demographics, West Brighton is a diverse area, home to a mix of Irish, Germans, Italians, African Americans, and Hispanics. The real estate market caters to an upper-middle-income group, with a range of affordable condos and townhomes available. All these factors make West Brighton a safe, family-friendly place to call home.
Violent Crimes (per 100,000 residents)
- Assault: 447.3 (national: 282.7)
- Murder: 0 (national: 6.1)
- Rape: – (national: 40.7)
- Robbery: 111.8 (national: 135.5)
Property Crimes
- Burglary: 135.4 (national: 500.1)
- Theft: 924 (national: 2,042.8)
- Motor Vehicle Theft: 23.5 (national: 284)
Want to Live in One of the Safest Neighborhoods in Staten Island? We Can Help!
Moving to Staten Island offers you the unique opportunity to live in one of the safest neighborhoods in the city, where community spirit thrives and quality of life is prioritized. Whether it’s the serene allure of Westerleigh, the coastal charm of Bay Terrace, or the vibrant atmosphere of Great Kills, there’s a neighborhood to suit everyone’s lifestyle.
At Metropolis Moving, we understand the importance of finding the perfect home in the right location. Our dedicated team is here to ensure your transition is smooth and stress-free, helping you settle into a community where safety, comfort, and convenience are a way of life. Contact us today to learn more about our Staten Island moving services and how we can help you relocate to one of the safest neighborhoods in Staten Island!
